The Ultimate NYC Vintage Roundup: Lingerie

Vintage this and vintage that, but do you really know where to get the most coveted items in fashion history? New York City’s vintage scene is immortalized through Sex and the City and the very real icons walking down SoHo every day. And listing the “best” stores would be a sham, given the endless niches and specialties. It’s only fair I do the same. 1202 MAGAZINE is bringing boots-on-the-ground journalism to vintage and consignment shops for every type of girly. So, starting with a personal favorite, I’m here to spill the beans on NYC’s top vintage lingerie stores (according to moi, of course).

Illisa’s Vintage Lingerie—1050 2nd Ave., New York, NY

Walking through the Manhattan Art Center, your eyes may glaze over at the stained glass Tiffany lamps, but the greatest treasure is on the bottom level—peeking over a greenery pond. A subtle hint to the luxurious feminine escapade you’re about to enter. Illisa Vintage Lingerie has been operated and owned for the last 40 years, one of the only large-scale vintage sellers. As she says, the girls “have about 10 pieces and nothing else. I have everything.”

The shop owner’s infectious confidence infiltrates every piece and customer. From gowns to sets to pumps and even men’s boxers, there is something for everyone. The rows are lined by size, so she’ll quickly tell you if you’re in the wrong area. Her care and attention come from her long history with fashion. Her mother was a fashion designer, and she taught her everything she knows.

But don’t conflate her passion as a hand-me-down; with bright eyes and a sneaky smile, she easily recounts the first vintage lingerie dress she put on. “It was a 1930s slip dress, and when I put it on, nothing has ever made me feel more sexy, girly, feminine, special.” And she aims for the same experience, whether with her loyal clients or Anthony Vaccarello, who bought an entire rack for his YSL Resort 2026 collection.

Orchard Corset—157 Orchard St., New York, NY

Submerged into the shopping experience of Orchard Street, one might walk right past this corset shop. Oh, what a loss that would be when you could walk into the corsetry magic of your dreams. Run by Peggy and Ralph Bergstein and founded by Bergstein’s parents in 1968, the family business has continually worked to meet women where they are and show them to their desires.

Typically, clients come in, and Peggy directs them to pieces that fit and align with the aesthetic they are trying to achieve. The walls are lined with white boxes and bust numbers scratched on the outside, a system that works especially for Peggy. Now, I know you’re thinking where the vintage comes into play. With such a large collection, Orchard Corset amasses lots of vintage deadstock corsets, providing a non-ubiquitous experience for everyone who walks in.

A.W. Kaufman—73 Orchard St., New York, NY

Vintage is history; it’s family, and that's what defines A.W. Kaufman. The family-owned and run business has operated since 1924, and owner Miriam curates the experience for you. While many newer vintage stores indulge in the store's aesthetics, shaping a world of whimsy, Kaufman values the storage and archival nature of every piece.

Often kept in labeled bins and plastic dry-cleaning bags, the pieces hold a mystical corner of every space in the store. Most pieces are imported from Europe, but the showstoppers are vintage lingerie from Dior to Oscar de la Renta, whether slip skirts or matching bra and panties.

Les Miss—283 Mott St., New York, NY

Rooted in color and excitement, Les Miss is bringing the full force of Y2K joy to the streets of Mott. Founded and owned by Leah Gans, it transformed a small, ambitious place into a color-coded, purse-covered wall of “thank God I’m a woman” bliss. But we know what we are here for: the lingerie. It takes up nearly a whole wall, with buttery slip dresses to mid-range corsets.

You obviously can’t forget the doily bras in pinks, purples, and every shade of red. It’s known, by this list, that vintage lingerie or stores that specialize in it are hard to come by. Even on a smaller scale, Les Miss’ excitement comes from expanding how you think about wearing lingerie, with the styling process as important as the construction.

Nyla Stanford

Nyla is a psychological researcher turned thoughtful fashion and lifestyle writer, convinced she knows the nuances of life and surviving NYC. You can catch her either rambling about the laziness of a two-piece set or her partner of the week. Follow her on Instagram @eclectic_sweetie for good ideas on what to wear.

Next
Next

From 9 to 5 and 5 to 9, The Best NYC Bags to Carry It All